Even More Cakes That Fail Hilariously At Looking Like The Things They're Supposed To Look Like

Back by popular* demand! A brand new edition of Cakes Failing To Look Like The Things They're Supposed To Look Like!
[*The cats liked it.]
A Shamrock:
When the luck of the Irish has a bad day.
And then gets all its limbs cut off.
Balloons.
Literally the easiest thing you can make with cake:
WE'RE DOOMED.
A Football Helmet:
Alien skull. Final answer.
Flip-Flops:
If these look right to you, then someday you're going to make a podiatrist very, VERY happy.
Basketballs:
Or stick figures with no faces.
A School Bus:
Or so they claim.
I'm convinced this is actually a platypus named School Bus. See the little nostrils?
A Baseball Glove:
For the longest time I thought this was supposed to be turkey.
Then I saw the fingernails.
BONUS POP QUIZ!
Can you guess what this is supposed to be?
How about this one?
Answers in the comments!
Assuming someone guesses right!
[wicked grin]
Thanks to Anony M., Jennifer M., Matt M., Katie T., Maggie P., Sally N., Tracie T., Jennalee, & Lauren L. for the excuse to use John's favorite post title again.
Note from john: Someone just told me they were done with Cake Wrecks because Jen didn't give you guys the answer in the comments in a timely manner. Honestly, we thought it was fun seeing your guesses. Well, as far as we know, it's the Mad Men logo and a teapot. Unless we're wrong. Merry Christmas!
*****
Thank you for using our Amazon links to shop! USA, UK, Canada.
Reader Comments (295)
The last one - a teapot?
Got to be a baseball bat and a teapot!
Duck and tea pot?
Duck and tea pot?
Duck and tea pot?
1st bonus: literally no idea
2nd bonus: a teapot?
Also, that is definitely a platypus. And I'm pretty sure the "baseball glove" is growing mold.
The last one's a teapot! Not necessarily a teapot that one could pick up and pour from, but there are enough clues for me to guess. On the second-to-last one -- I got nothing. The first thing to pop into my head was a really stretched-out duck silhouette.
If you turn the baseball glove one upside down you have an udder. A scary, deformed udder.
As for my guesses I'm thinking a penguin sliding on its belly. The second one is a teapot.
First one: long black duck. Or shadow figure lying on a psychiatrist's couch while wearing a dunce cap. With a serious crick in his neck.
Second: teapot?
Is the second one a teapot? The first one looks like a whale with a birthday hat. Or a big red zit.
OK, the first one is a guy in a coffin. #2 is a teapot...do I win?
I'm guessing the second pop quiz entry is supposed to be a flowery teapot maybe? The first is OBVIOUSLY a corpse getting ready to rise from the dead with a party hat on his head! :)
First Bonus: No clue! Maybe one of those noise-maker party favors?
Second Bonus: A teapot!
The first one is the profile is a dead gnome. The second one is a teapot.
I'm going to say; Drag race car and tea pot for the last 2 respectively. However it could be a "dunce" in his coffin, and a fooofy princess dress.
Ok, Ok... I'm guessing the first one is an elderly earthworm with a birthday hat and the second is a fancy schmancy tea pot?
Ding Ding Ding?!?
Second one is clearly a teapot. The first one I think is supposed to be a Pileated Woodpecker.
Answers to the pop quiz: First, it is a base ball bat, with a base ball that is wearing a party hat. Second, an odd tea pot.
A Duck and a Tea Pot
A Duck and a Tea Pot
Would *like* yo think they're the sexy man on bear rug variation (this time on happy birthday bed) and a teapot.
Don't look like either.
There WERE baseball mitts that didn't have webbing and were five fingers way back in the start of the sport, bit this one still of by 400 feet....
The first one is a duck. Or is it a brown M&M wearing a gnome hat riding a baluga whale?
The second is "clearly" Cinderella's pumpkin carriage. Or maybe not.
I don't watch much tv, but the first bonus one looks like the Mad Men Logo.
*Raises hand*
Uh, yes, but why would a baseball glove have fingernails?
The last one is obviously a tea pot. All of the previous posters can't be wrong! Bonus feature: It's on wheels! Whee. "Hellooo--? You, on the other end of the table? Be a lamb and roll the tea down to me? Thanks ever so much." ( Hope this doesn't turn into an "EP-POT"...) =^~.~^=
Batmobile and a teapot.
Respectively.
I was thinking the first is a penguin? A really long, weird penguin.
The second, I could totally see a princess carriage.
Is the first pop quiz a...pipe?
That top one's a nice tree, but trunks aren't usually green too. Just leaves.
I'm going for loon (because, hello! Crazy as a ....) and teapot. Or extra-fancy chamber pot.
OMG... The second to last one isn't supposed to be Mad Men, is it?? The silhouette of Don Draper with his arm over the chair... With a party hat... Ugh. That's it, isn't?
huh. i thought the 2nd one was a pumpkin w cinderella popping out of it....
...but i guess it's a teapot. :)
Obviously the first one is an Egyptian hieroglyphic of a guy (I think the Egyptian kings were called "guys", right?) reclining on a couch, party hat attached by a rubber band. The second one has to be the Enterprise (the star ship, not the aircraft carrier) because it is going in a direction no one has thought to go before. And for good reason.
I'm going to be geeky for a second . . . I really think that first one is the profile of the Star Wars species, Ortolan, with the long nose. I would include a picture but can't. You can just google "Star Wars Ortolan." The black ball is the eye and the red represents his ear . . Just tell I'm wrong! :)
I've seen enough bad cakes to know that the first one is a lonely Shriner, and the second one is a baby carriage, It looks too much like a teapot to really *be* a teapot.
It's a dead duck, because it's a "milestone" birthday usually celebrated with black balloons and over-the-hill cakes. You know what Maxine says..."I'd rather be over-the-hill than buried under it."
And a teapot. Or a magical mirror.
Pop quiz answers
The Mad Men logo (only birthday themed)
Aaaand probably a teapot, like everyone else has said.
Mr. Hanky the Christmas Poo having a lie down? And a teapot. Yes.
1st one is Moby Dick and 2nd one is a teapot
I don't see a duck at all on the 1st pop quiz one. A whale, maybe. But I'm guessing a pipe, ahem, of some kind. I can't say the 2nd one looks like a teapot, but that would be my guess of what it is supposed to be.
First one, I think is a Madmen logo. Guy with an arm on the couch with an added party hat and letters. Like this: https://d3ui957tjb5bqd.cloudfront.net/uploads/2013/09/mad-men-logo.jpg
Then again, I may be looking for logic in all the wrong places.
The first one is the Don Draper shadow from Mad Men Logo.
I'll go with the tea pot for the second one.
Maybe those aren't "fingernails" on that "turkey"...and maybe that's not a baseball glove, either. Maybe it's a condom for quintuplets who don't mind sharing. Maybe I'm even more twisted than I thought.
The second one: definitely a teapot.
The first: I'm thinking a dachshund with a party hat.
Maybe?
One is supposed to be the Mad Men logo!!! I don't know why they added the party hat, though.
"Why a duck?" (to quote one of the lamer Marx Brothers jokes). I think the first of the unidentifiables looks like a rather abstract representation of a hash pipe. Please don't tell my kids I said this.
The second one is some kind of bracketed teapot which would be impossible to pour, even if it weren't made of cupcakes.
The second to last one is supposed to recall the Mad Men title logo, with Don in a snappy party hat.
2nd to last cake: embalmed Lenin laid on on a mortuary slab in a party hat.
Last Cake: anthropomorphic teapot doing a racy "boudoir dance" for that special someone
Sorry my guess posted 4 times at least. Every time I tried to post it came up with an error. So I tried it a few more times. But I guess they did post after all. Sorry!
I had to go and look. Oh God, it really is meant to be the Mad Men logo.
Also, I think Angela's fairly sure it's a duck and a teapot.
;)