Autumn Terrors

When you see your typical bakery display filling up with disembodied plastic fingers and red corn syrup drenched eyeballs you know Halloween is nearly upon us. Of course, those cakes are trying to be gross, gory, and/or creepy.
[sing-song voice] Bo-ring!
Personally, I prefer the cakes that were going for cutesy, but didn't quite make it. You know, like this:

So anyway, you can keep your rat-gnawed arms and zombie brain cakes; to me, no baked good will ever be as terrifying as this thing:
Denise, Surlana, Matt L., & Kourtny, I will never look at fried eggs the same way again. Thanks.
- Related Wreckage: RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!!
Reader Comments (106)
I can't even begin to fathom what that last cake might be. It looks like one of those Fierie puppets from the Labyrinth...only one that's been cross-bred with a duck and has had its eyes replaced with breakfast foods.
Oh, God, I'm going to have nightmares about a egg-eyed Fierie-duck now.
WV - sesse: I cannot sesse how wreckerators come up with these damned ideas.
Okay, um...I kinda like the last one. At least it is something you don't see every day.
BRAAAAAIIIIINNNNNSSSSS!!!
What the frickity heck is that thing? And why can't I stop staring at it?
I like the "bale out" cake. Too much icing, but it's funny and clever.
But the "I want you" cake is just scary. Especially those two random backwards fingers.
What the fronk is that hard boiled egg/cornucopia thing?
I LOVE the hard-boiled egg eyes on the last one...
Yikes - the boiled egg eyeball monster!
that last one will haunt me for the rest of my life
". . . or, at least, I think I want you. I might want him. Can't really tell anymore, what with these crooked eyes and all."
Billy, nothing. That's Spud!!
Farmer Pickles finally gave him his comeuppance. We've always wondered how this village tolerated the personification of pure evil for so long.
What is that last one even supposed to be? It's like the leaf pile came to life or something. Eek!
Deviled egg sandwich cookies....why didn't *I* think of that! :slaps forehead:
How appropriate that this demon has devilish eyes, though!
WV: mamwgdat--what my 2 yo said when she saw the picture.....before running away in terror! ;)
First comment! Woo!
Can I just say, I wish the bakeries here had baked goods as awesome as these ones.
I think the first one is Basketball Jones - "Bassetball Jones! Oh, Bassetball Jones!" The second one was the last straw. The third one - snot monster? The last one looks like a deviled egg cornucopia.
Gah. What is that thing???
I did a black cat cake (dark chocolate cake; dark chocolate icing with just a bit of black color to take it the rest of the way.) That went over well, no grossness needed!
What IS that last one? I think I see a mouth, and maybe some eyes. Could we request a different angle for that one? Please? Ok, ok, how about just some mental soap please. I'l be having nightmares tonight.
I love the random leaf on the last one. Nice touch Wreckerator! I guess it must be a clue to what this thing is. Be careful kids, when you are out this Halloween: The Pile of Leaves Monster might get you!!!
agirlinherkitchen.blogspot.com
hilarious! I'm heading out to see what our Wal-Mart bakery has concocted this year...I'm sure it will be good for a laugh, or two!
OMG. What is that last creature supposed to be?!?!
Slightly OT...my 4 year old just wandered in while I had CW open on the screen and said, "Heyyyyyy...those babies are sitting on carrots! That's SILLY!" Then giggled maniacally.
This from a kid who decorated her own birthday cake, including pushing jellybeans through the icing into the cake, stacking them six or seven at a time, claiming those were rabbit families in holes.
See, even little kids with huge imaginations are perplexed by the naked mohawk babies on carrots!
That last one looks like the Deviled Egg eye Monster
"It was a night... just like tonight..."
The last one TOTALLY reminds me of Large Marge from Pee-Wee's Big Adventure. I just used to run screaming from the room during that scene when I was little. Oh, the trauma.
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/80/246304911_01e2d85720.jpg
In the name of our savior! WHAT IS THAT THING! MY GOD! MY GOD! WHY HAVE YOU FORSAKEN ME?
Although, if that's all buttercream between those cookies, send 'em my way.
LOL. I would actually buy that last one. It was totally disturbing, of course, but I think it looks just how the decorator wanted it to. Hmmm...noww I'm thinking of making a really scary cake for Halloween.
That last one makes my teeth hurt!
WV: tactrat . . . . You'd think a rat would have more tact than to make one of these cakes! Not to be confused with packrat . . . which these wrecks seem to reflect everything but the kitchen sink!
I WANT YOU!!! LMAO what were they going for with that cake? an Uncle Sam/Alien combo? or is he just in the moode for some lovin' ? what the heck!
...poor aligod. *that makes me laugh every time i think of it.. btw.
Um, yeah, that bale of hay has penis hands.
Please tell me that last one isn't just frosting. Because it looks to me like it's just piles and piles of frosting. I love frosting as much as (and maybe more than) the next person, but my pancreas is quivering in fear looking at that thing.
okay, i can't get past the green monster thingy. i like that it enlarges for closer inspection.
it's touching that he wants me, but honestly, his sign should read, "i need some visine ... and perhaps a manicure for my two fingers."
yikes.
"And when they pulled the driver's body from the twisted, burning wreck. It looked like THIS... "
The last cake is clearly an Egg McMuffin monster.
Spud, Large Marge...great comments today. That last "cake" is a doozy.
Thank god someone else noticed!
Every single one of those wrecks made me think "What the f?" I'm going to wonder all day long what that green thing was supposed to be, and now, thanks to the last one, I'm craving deviled eggs...
"The monster mash just got a leeetle bit awkward."
Hahahahahaha!
I'm reasonably certain that last one is from Labyrinth with David Bowie. I'd say it's pretty wreck-tastic if I'm right or wrong.
By the way. Labyrinth still scares the bagezus out of me and I'm 28.
Love how the green one doesn't even have writing on the cake! They just put a note in there with I Want You, which doesn't really make much sense anyway.
What in the name of Gaknar is that thing?
I think my eyes have started to deteriorate!
Oh my. That monster cake is so creepy on its own, and the "I want you" sticker just makes it even worse. If I saw that in a grocery store I would most likely run screaming from the bakery department.
The last one looks like Animal from the Muppets to me.
"Bale-out". Cute!
Amy B-H
I like how the first one is actually a hamburger cake re-dressed for Halloween.
I actually love the last one.
Looks like what would happen if Gizmo and Spike had their own offspring..
( I'm partial to Gemlins since my house is over run with them on a daily basis! )
The first one looks like the hamburgers that grow in McDonaldland. Which - the hamburgers were *alive*, with eyes and mouth, but they were picked to be eaten... by Mayor McCheese! Creepy.
Seriously... what is that last one?!
I prefer eggs in my cake, not hard boiled and on the cake. EWW
Frightening! They all look like variations of classic Dr. Who monsters. If anyone needs me I'll be quivering behind the couch.
Gremlins.. attacked my keyboard as I was typing.. AAHH
The last one looks like the McDonald's Egg McMuffin Monster.
Does anyone else see deviled eggs made from frosting in a cornucopia on the last wreck? Or is it just me...